HomeIdeas & MediaJournalism & Mass Media

Gay Talese

b. 1932 Specialist

The tailor's son who turned magazine profiles into literature

Portrait of Gay Talese
David Shankbone — 2006-08-14 — CC BY 2.5 via Wikimedia Commons

Talese was born February 7, 1932, in Ocean City, New Jersey, the son of a Calabrian immigrant tailor and an Italian mother who ran a dress shop; he later credited hours spent listening to customers in his parents' shops for teaching him how people talk about themselves. He graduated from the University of Alabama in 1953 with a journalism degree earned, he has said, mostly to avoid flunking out, and moved to New York to take a copyboy's job at the Times. Assigned to the obituary desk as what he considered a punishment, he found instead that writing about the dead taught him to compress a life; he moved up to sports and features before Esquire's Harold Hayes hired him away in 1965 to write without a beat at all.

At Esquire, Talese became one of the writers Tom Wolfe would later name a founder of New Journalism, reporting nonfiction with a novelist's attention to scene and interior detail. His 1966 profile Frank Sinatra Has a Cold, about a subject who refused to be interviewed, is still taught as a model of the form; The Kingdom and the Power (1969) turned that method on his own newspaper, and Honor Thy Father (1971) spent years inside a Mafia family. His most ambitious project, Thy Neighbor's Wife (1981), took nine years and required him to manage a massage parlor and run a sex shop to research American sexual behavior firsthand. The Voyeur's Motel (2016), built on a motel owner's account of spying on guests for decades, drew scrutiny when parts proved unverifiable, a credibility problem Talese first disavowed, then walked back.

The method that made Talese's reputation — total immersion, no notebook in sight, years spent simply being present — also makes his reporting hard to check against anything but his own notes, and The Voyeur's Motel became the clearest case of the risk: Talese built a book on Gerald Foos's diaries without verifying basic claims in them, some of which turned out false. In November 2017, at a Vanity Fair gala days after his peers broke the Harvey Weinstein story, he suggested publicly that women who stayed silent about assault for years bore some responsibility for what followed, remarks he did not walk back the way he eventually walked back his doubts about Foos. He has also said, without apparent hesitation, that he could not name a woman writer he admired, a comment that produced its own social-media reckoning in 2016.

Talese turned 94 in February 2026 and is still publishing; Bartleby and Me, a 2023 collection about the reporter's craft, was his most recent book. Whether he is remembered chiefly as the writer who proved a magazine profile could be literature, or as a cautionary case for immersive journalism's blind spots and a run of on-the-record comments about women that aged badly, is not a question his own long career has settled — both arguments are still being made about him while he is still alive to read them.

Lifespan

15401700180019002030

Gay Talese's life against the full span of the corpus — the fading end marks a life still in progress.

Notable works

  • Frank Sinatra Has a Cold article
    Esquire profile written without cooperation from its subject; a landmark of New Journalism
    1966
  • The Kingdom and the Power book
    A history of The New York Times, his former employer
    1969
  • Honor Thy Father book
    Years inside the Bonanno crime family
    1971
  • Thy Neighbor's Wife book
    Nine years researching American sexual behavior
    1981
  • The Voyeur's Motel book
    Built on an unverified source's diaries; drew a public credibility dispute
    2016

Life in brief

with age at each point
  • February 7, 1932 aged 0 Born in Ocean City, New Jersey
  • 1953 aged ~21 Moves to New York and joins The New York Times as a copyboy
  • 1959 aged ~27 Marries editor Nan Ahearn
  • 1965 aged ~33 Leaves the Times for Esquire
  • April 1966 aged 34 Publishes Frank Sinatra Has a Cold
  • 1981 aged ~49 Publishes Thy Neighbor's Wife after nine years of research
  • April 2016 aged 84 Publishes The Voyeur's Motel, then disputes its own source's credibility
  • November 2017 aged 85 Draws criticism for comments on sexual-assault accusers at a Vanity Fair gala
  • 2023 aged ~91 Publishes Bartleby and Me

Related

Contemporaries

Ideas & Media, born within 25 years
Journalism